Orthographic Mapping

    ← Back to blog section

    Published on

    Frequently Asked Questions: This optional section addresses the most common questions that interested parents and educators have when looking for the information on this page.

    • What is orthographic mapping?
      • It is the cognitive process by which readers transition from decoding words to storing a stable representation of the pronunciation, spelling, and meaning of a word in long-term memory for instant recognition.
    • Why is phonemic awareness necessary for fluent reading?
      • Phonemic awareness is the cognitive ability that allows readers to hear and manipulate individual sounds (phonemes) in spoken words. This is required to "anchor" letters to sounds; without it, words appear as arbitrary shapes that cannot be mapped to long-term memory.
    • What is the "self-teaching hypothesis"?
      • This is the process where a student uses their phonemic awareness and phonics knowledge to decode unfamiliar words independently. Each successful decoding event serves to map the word, expanding their sight vocabulary without formal instruction.
    • What is the primary cause of reading difficulties?
      • Most reading difficulties stem from a deficit in phonemic awareness. This prevents students from forming stable mappings, forcing them to rely on inefficient visual memorization or laborious letter-by-letter decoding.
    • What specific exercises have shown to help students with reading difficulties?
      • Beyond basic blending and segmenting, research highlights advanced phonemic awareness tasks such as substitution (changing a sound), deletion (removing a sound), and reversal (reversing the order of sounds). Interventions that include these exercises have shown that over 90% of students can read at grade level with correct instruction.

    One of the key questions in literacy education is how fluent readers are capable of recognizing words so quickly and effortlessly. Their facility greatly contrasts with the laborious process that beginning readers go through to decode words letter by letter. The answer lies in the concept of orthographic mapping, which describes the cognitive process by which readers go from decoding a word to storing a stable representation of the pronunciation, spelling, and meaning of a word in their long-term memory for effortless and instant recognition.

    The Process of Orthographic Mapping🔗

    The research on orthographic mapping has extensively proven that the acquisition of fluent reading in phonetic writing systems, such as English, is mostly a phonological process, that is, it relies on the ability to hear and manipulate the sounds of spoken words. In particular, it relies on a more fine-tuned ability called phonemic awareness, which is the ability to identify and manipulate the individual sounds (phonemes) in spoken words.

    Let us explore how this ability creates fluent readers by exploring how students with a highly developed phonemic awareness learn to read new words. When such a student is exposed to written material, for example by having their parent read them a book, they will start recognizing that the words they hear are composed of individual sounds and that those sounds match the letters they see on the page. For example, when they hear the word "cat", they can quickly identify that it is composed of three phonemes: /k/ /æ/ /t/, so they can also infer that the letters "c", "a", and "t" correspond to those sounds. This ability might sound trivial to adult fluent readers, but it is important to remember that breaking up spoken words into their individual sounds is not an innate ability and is one that is rarely required during speech.

    Once the student has seen the word "cat" a few times, they are able to immediately recognize the word without having to decode it letter by letter. Over time, they will encounter more words and map them in their long-term memory, building a large sight1 vocabulary of instantly recognizable words. In adult fluent readers, this sight vocabulary can contain tens of thousands of words, allowing them to read the words quickly and to focus their cognitive resources on comprehension.

    When these students are explicitly taught the mappings of letters to sounds through systematic phonics instructions, they can leverage their phonemic awareness to quickly go through the curriculum and gain the ability to decode unfamiliar words. After that, they gain the ability to teach themselves new words by reading independently, which further expands their sight vocabulary and reading fluency. This process is known as the self-teaching hypothesis and is the basis for how fluent readers continue to grow their vocabulary throughout their lives way after formal reading instruction has ended. For students with the highest levels of phonemic awareness, this process of orthographic mapping can even happen without explicit instruction, simply by being exposed to written material.

    What about exceptions and irregular words that do not follow the standard letter-sound mappings? The key for how orthographic mapping allows the formation of such a large sight vocabulary lies in being able to efficiently store mappings of words that are taught as "exceptions". In the case of an irregular word such as "have", the student only needs to store the mapping of the irregular part and can rely on the stable mappings they already have for the rest of the word. In this case, the student only needs to store the mapping of the letter "a" to the sound /æ/. The same efficiency applies to all irregular words, even to foreign loanwords that do not follow English phonemic rules, such as "anime" or "ballet".

    How Orthographic Mapping Relates to Reading Difficulties🔗

    The theory of orthographic mapping also explains the cause of most reading difficulties. The most common reason for struggling readers is a deficit in phonemic awareness, which prevents them from being able to break down spoken words into their individual sounds. Take the same example of a student encountering the word "cat" while their parent reads them a book. The student will not quickly understand that the word is composed of three phonemes and the letters will appear to them as an arbitrary sequence of shapes. As a result, they will not be able to form stable mappings of the word in their long-term memory. They might be able to recognize a small amount of words through visual memorization, but visual memory is highly inefficient and breaks down as soon as they are exposed to material beyond simple leveled readers.

    Without the ability to recognize most of the words they see instantly, these students will have to decode letter by letter, which is a slow and laborious process that consumes most of their cognitive resources. As a result, they will struggle to comprehend what they read, which further reduces their exposure to written material and prevents them from developing their reading skills. These students might continue to struggle even if they are given explicit phonics instruction, as most of the phonics programs available are not designed with orthographic mapping and phonemic awareness in mind.

    However, when these students are given explicit and correct instruction that focuses on developing their phonemic awareness to the level required for orthographic mapping, most of them can catch up to their peers and become fluent readers. The research has shown that these students require more intensive instruction in the form of making them perform additional phonemic awareness exercises such as:

    • Substitution: changing one phoneme in a word to create a new word (e.g., changing the /k/ in "cat" to /b/ to create "bat").
    • Deletion: removing one phoneme from a word to create a new word (e.g., removing the /k/ from "cat" to create "at").
    • Reversal: reversing the order of phonemes in a word to create a new word (e.g., reversing the phonemes in "cat" to create "tac").

    These tasks are in addition to the more standard tasks of blending (combining phonemes to form words) and segmenting (breaking words into phonemes) that were explored earlier. Interventions that focus on developing phonemic awareness through these tasks for the students that need them have shown that over 90% of all students can read at grade level with correct instruction. For a more detailed explanation of these interventions, you can read chapter 11 of the book Essentials of Assessing, Preventing, and Overcoming Reading Difficulties

    1

    This term is not to be confused with the concept of a "sight word", which refers to a word that is taught to be recognized by sight without decoding. Orthographic mapping actually disproves that words should ever be taught as complete visual chunks.